Recently I found myself down in Hayward on my way to the adult playground in Newark known as a skatepark. It was a hot day and as I made my way through a long section of business park I got an oh so sweet whiff of pot pies. When there’s a mirage can you smell stuff too? I thought I was delusional but soon enough I saw it. Pot Pie Paradise AND Deli.
Seeing this place appear out of the business park darkness was a revelation. It’s a Pot Pie Paradise, which is hard to find because usually pot pies create total slums of extreme poverty with flaky crust and tweakers everywhere.
But not only is this place a paradise, it also has a deli, which is an important distinction. Take it from me, just because some place is all nice and Heaven-like doesn’t mean they have potato salad by the pound my loyal readers! Plus according to the sign it seems like they also have Cum so that’s tight:
I went inside and was awestruck, similar to how one might feel upon entering the Pearly Gates of Jesus’ kingdom. Shit was all clean and organized and they even had an aquarium:
I got in line thinking, yeah whatever, I’ll just decide what I want when I got to the register. How many fuckin pot pies can they possibly offer? It turns out they have like 38 different ones! God damn!
I panicked and got the ‘Classic American Chicken’. Usually I’m not that boring but it seemed like that would have been the most solid option upon which to review a place’s pot pie skills. The Creole Gumbo and Indo Lamb Curry are definitely more my jam flavor wise but as a pot pie I just thought maybe that’s a little crazy. That’s like going to first base and suddenly someone has a finger in your urethra. Gotta work your way up to that kinda shit probably, but fuck if I know I’m a food blogger not a sex therapist.
Because California is disease ridden, I had to sit outside on this bench. It wasn’t that bad.
To accompany my meal I also got some macaroni salad because I’m a white dude and we love mayonnaise and pasta. I don’t know why but rules are rules. I eagerly ripped into the flaky crust of my pie to reveal its molten savory filling:
I can’t even remember the last time I had a pot pie prior to this, but god damn this thing was so good. It was pure comfort food. Like so comforting I felt like a fetus inside a womb again without a care in the world. Well, except for sitting outside in the hot sun because of a pandemic but still….almost fetus like comfort levels were attained. The filling was crazy hot but luckily I had a fat cup of nice cool mayo infused macaroni to cool my mouth down.
I would definitely recommend coming here, especially if for some reason you are in this business park conducting some sort of business. Check out this review from Hayward’s bootleg version of David Cross: